data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/efde4/efde46b795524ecbead0925d893384807bbc5b3a" alt="2012-2"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b186d/b186d8b2a52d0d970efe89e5a126a0340169e7c1" alt="2012-3"
Top is with flash, bottom is without. Seriously, aren't these beautiful? The shades clockwise from the left are Golden, Rust, Walnut and Red Bean Pie.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c008/8c008ed18fa7c02e252d2dfa89d7f44055515e90" alt="2012-1"
All are described as shimmer and/or metallic.
Golden |
Rust - a dupe for MAC Cranberry too apparently! |
Walnut |
Red Bean Pie - poss dupe for MAC Trax or Sketch?? Similar gilded purple shade. |
Beautiful. In terms of texture they are all soft and smooth, Red Bean Pie is the only one that was a bit dusty and you can see that in the swatch pics.
Rust, Golden, Red Bean Pie, Walnut both pics in natural light. |
![]() |
The longer swatch is without UDPP and the smaller dot below is with it |
![]() |
Dear God, I have sent myself to sleep with all these pics! |
Initially I put Golden all over my lower lid - it was very golden indeed! I then put Walnut on the outer corner of my eye and then Rust into the crease, at this point I was wondering if this was all going to come together or not! I decided to spread Walnut over the whole lower lid to take down some of the brassy'ness. I then felt the whole thing really needed grounding so I applied Urban Decay Whisky pencil on upper and lower lash and water line, which seemed to suddenly pull everything together. I then ran a bit of Hustle from the Naked palette over the lower lash line and then smudged a bit into the crease to take down Rust which was dominating. It was only after blending that I realised that Red Bean Pie might just have been perfect instead of Hustle - next time!
Now all I need is some one to buy me the Tom Ford Burnished Amber Quad and I can do a proper comparison! But here are the pics, what do you think:
![]() |
Thanks again Klara for the pics of the real deal! |
Not a dupe, of course, but not totally wide of the mark either! Hope you enjoyed this marathon of a post!
I totally forgot to thank Klara for the use of her photo of the Tom Ford quad again, sorry Klara! xx
ReplyDeleteI think thats a fantastic dupe and they look great on you!
ReplyDeleteThanks Charlie, it was fun trawling the internet for NYX dupes and I am pleased with how they look on too! x
DeleteIt is great that you have posted all the color swatches with so much care and from the palette as well as after application.It has a nice glide and flow after use...like the earth shades too.
ReplyDeleteThank you, these are lovely eye shadows and I would definitely recommend them.
DeleteThose berry/warm colours look great on you. Sorry I haven't commented in a while but now I'm going off to check that you haven't wearing any rogue pasty looking makeup! lol
ReplyDeletelol 'rogue pasty looking makeup'! Not guilty, nothing pasty here! xx
Delete